At the same price, you can choose between a fully loaded electric micro SUV or an entry-level variant of a slightly larger electric SUV with more performance.
Over the past few years, the Indian EV market has grown in both size and popularity, with carmakers introducing a number of new electric cars across different price segments. Given the increasing number of mass electric vehicles on sale today, it’s natural for some models to overlap in pricing, even if they fit into different segments. In this story, we are taking a look at the price overlap of the top-spec Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range and the entry-level Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro.
How much do they cost?
Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range | Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro |
Rs 15.49 lakh | Rs 15.49 lakh |
All prices, ex-showroom across India
The Tata Punch Empowered Plus S Long Range variant mentioned here with the additional AC fast charger unit is priced at Rs 50,000. The Mahindra XUV400, on the other hand, recently got a new ‘Pro’ variant with more features, making it Rs 50,000 more affordable across the entire lineup.
size compared
DIMENSIONS | Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range | Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro |
Length | 3857 mm | 4200 mm |
Width | 1742 mm | 1821 mm |
Height | 1633 mm | 1634 mm |
wheelbase | 2445 mm | 2600mm |
surface | 190mm | No |
boot space | 366 liters | 378 liters |
-
The XUV400 comes with a large luggage area which facilitates carrying a few more soft bags for your weekend trips. However, the Punch EV also gets the option of a small “frunk” for some additional storage.
powertrain check
Specifications | Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range | Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro |
battery pack | 35 kilowatt | 34.5 kilowatts |
number of electric motors | 1 | 1 |
Power | 122 ps | 150 ps |
Torque: | 140nm | 310nm |
claimed limit | 421 km | 375 km |
-
At this price, both the EVs get similar capacity battery packs, although the Punch EV has a larger battery pack. It has been claimed that its range is more than 50 km.
-
That said, if you want more performance from your EV, the Mahindra XUV400 should be your choice, with more than double the torque.
Read also: Take a look at the top 10 best-selling cars in February 2024
charge
accuser | charging time | |
Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range | Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro | |
3.3kW AC charger (10-100%) | 13.5 hours | 13.5 hours |
7.2kW AC fast charger (10-100%) | 5 hours | 6.5 hours |
50kW DC fast charger | 56 minutes | 50 minutes |
-
Both the Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range and XUV400 EC Pro take the same time to charge using a 3.3kW AC charger.
-
However, the Tata EV can be charged quicker using an AC fast charger than the Mahindra XUV400.
equipment on board
features | Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range | Mahindra XUV400 EC Pro |
external |
|
|
interior part |
|
|
comfort and convenience |
|
|
infotainment | ||
Security |
|
-
The fully loaded Punch EV gets premium features like ventilated front seats, wireless phone charging, dual 10.25-inch displays (one for instrumentation and the other for infotainment), and leatherette upholstery.
-
On the other hand, the XUV400 EC Pro is loaded with only a few comfort and convenience features like push-button start/stop, dual-zone AC, keyless entry and all four power windows.
-
In terms of safety, the Punch EV is slightly ahead with technology like 360-degree camera, six airbags and electronic parking brake with auto hold.
-
Mahindra is offering the safety net of the XUV400 eC Pro with some basic features which include dual front airbags, electronic stability program and rear parking sensors.
Decision
It is clear that the Punch EV Empowered Plus S Long Range offers more value for the price. Higher range, faster charging options and a long list of premium comforts make it a far better package than the base-spec XUV400.
However, if you prefer something with a true EV drive experience with more road presence and rapid acceleration at increased range, then the XUV400 EC Pro is more suitable for you. Its larger dimensions, which lead to a more spacious cabin, make it slightly more suitable as a family car. Not to forget, the XUV400 has the upper hand when it comes to boot space, which will help in packing a few extra soft bags for a weekend family trip.
So, which of these two electric SUVs will you choose and why? Tell us in the comments.